Dental Directory Link Quality: How to Evaluate Listing Opportunities

A dental directory listing is worth having when five things are true. Real people in your area use the site. Google indexes the listing page. The site is about dentistry, health or your town. Someone checks listings before they go live. And the site does not sell followed links for ranking. If a directory fails two or more of these tests, skip it, even when the listing is free.

We built the scorecard in this guide from the Google spam policies, the Google guide to qualifying outbound links and real chamber directories in Grand Rapids and Des Moines. Use it to sort the listing offers that land in your inbox before anyone on your team spends time on them.

Request Dental SEO Quote

We only use this to respond to your request.

Check that Google indexes the directory listing pages

A listing page that Google has not indexed cannot send you search traffic. It also cannot pass any value through its link. So the first test is simple and free.

Search Google for site: followed by the directory domain and the word dentist. For example, type site:exampledirectory.com dentist. If Google returns real dentist listing pages, the directory passes. If it returns nothing, or only the home page and a sign-up page, the listings are not being indexed.

Then go one step further. Search for a practice that is already listed there, using its name plus the directory name. If that listing page shows up, new listings are likely to be indexed too. If several listings are missing, the directory may have too many thin pages for Google to bother with.

Search for your own town to see if patients use the directory

A good directory brings patients, not only links. The quickest way to judge this is to search the way a patient would. Type “dentist in” plus your town and look at the first two pages of Google results.

If the directory shows up for your town, or for nearby towns, local patients are likely to find it. Healthcare directories, local newspapers and city guides often appear in these results. If the directory never appears for any town you test, its listings are unlikely to send you patients. In that case the only possible value is the link, and the link alone is rarely worth paying for.

Dental team showing a patient information on a tablet in the treatment room
Photo: Pexels

You can also check if the directory gets reviews and activity. Look for recent patient reviews, updated listings and staff replies. A directory where the newest review is several years old is not being used.

Judge if the directory is about dentistry or your town

Relevance matters more than size. A link from a local chamber of commerce or a dental association tells search engines something about your practice. A link from a global list of every business type tells them very little.

Sort each opportunity into one of four groups:

  • Dental and oral health directories: Sites that list only dentists or dental specialists, such as association member finders and specialist referral lists.
  • Health directories: Sites that list doctors, dentists and other providers, where patients compare clinicians.
  • Local directories: Chamber of commerce lists, city guides, local news directories and neighborhood sites.
  • General directories: Sites that list every type of business in every country.

The first three groups are worth a closer look. The fourth group is where most link spam lives. Google lists “low-quality directory or bookmark site links” as a type of link spam in its spam policies.

Look at how the directory shows your listing

Two directories can both be “free” and still give very different value. Before you sign up, open an existing dental listing and check what it shows. We compared chamber directories and found the gap was wide.

The Greater Des Moines Partnership lists 16 dentists under its Dental category. Each listing shows the address, phone number and, for most, a map link. The category page does not link to the practices’ websites. The Grand Rapids Chamber, by contrast, shows a Visit Site link on most dental listings, plus a phone number, a Member Since year and social links.

Both listings help confirm your name, address and phone number. Only one of them gives you a link that a patient can click through to book. When you compare offers, check these listing features:

  • Website link: Does the listing link to your site, and is the link on the category page, the profile page or both?
  • Profile depth: Can you add a description, hours, photos and services?
  • Reviews: Can patients leave reviews, and can you reply?
  • Category choice: Is there a dentist category, or are you lumped in with “health and beauty”?

Every link on a web page can carry a rel attribute that tells Google how to treat it. Google asks site owners to mark paid links and ads with rel=”sponsored”. It asks them to mark user-generated links, such as comments and forum posts, with rel=”ugc”. The rel=”nofollow” value covers cases where neither applies.

Google Search Central guide on qualifying outbound links with sponsored, ugc and nofollow
Screenshot: developers.google.com

To see the attribute, right-click the link on an existing listing and choose Inspect in Chrome. The rel value appears inside the link tag. A paid listing that uses rel=”sponsored” or rel=”nofollow” is playing by Google’s rules. That is a good sign about the directory, even though the link will not pass ranking credit.

Be careful with paid directories that promise followed links. Google treats “buying or selling links for ranking purposes” as link spam. It says paid links are fine only when they are qualified with sponsored or nofollow. So a directory that sells followed links for SEO is breaking Google’s rules, and the links it sells count as link spam.

Spot the signs of a low-quality dental directory

Most poor directories look alike once you know what to check. Run through this list in a few minutes for any new offer.

  • It accepts anything: Dentists sit next to casinos, payday loans and essay writing services.
  • It sells rankings: The sales page talks about link juice, domain authority or page-one rankings instead of patients.
  • It has no editorial check: Listings go live the moment you pay, with no review of the practice details.
  • It has endless outbound links: Category pages list hundreds of businesses with no descriptions, only names and links.
  • It offers bulk or automated submissions: Google lists automated programs that create links as link spam.
  • It wants a reciprocal link: The directory asks you to link back to it in exchange. Google names excessive link exchanges as link spam too.
  • Its listings are stale: Practices that closed years ago are still listed with old phone numbers.

One warning sign may be an accident. Two or more usually mean the directory exists to sell links.

Score each listing opportunity with our checklist

We use a simple ten-point scorecard. Give each test the points shown, add them up and act on the total.

TestHow to checkPoints
Listing pages are indexedsite: search for the domain plus dentist2
Appears for local dentist searchesSearch “dentist in” plus your town and nearby towns2
Dental, health or local focusRead the categories and other listings2
Listing links to your websiteOpen an existing dental listing1
Profile allows description, hours and photosOpen an existing dental listing1
Editorial review before listings go liveRead the submission rules or ask1
Paid links marked sponsored or nofollow, or listing is freeInspect the link on an existing listing1

A score of 7 to 10 means the directory is worth your time. A score of 4 to 6 is fine for a free listing but not for a paid one. A score of 3 or less means skip it. Any directory that sells followed links for ranking should be skipped whatever it scores, because it breaks Google’s link spam rules.

Weigh the price against the patients the listing can bring

A paid listing should pay for itself in patients, not in links. Ask the directory how many people visit the dentist pages in your area each month. Then compare that with the cost of a new patient from your other channels. If they cannot give you numbers, treat the listing as unproven.

Memberships are a slightly different case. Chamber dues buy events, networking and newsletter mentions as well as the directory listing. Judge them on the whole package. Our guide to getting listed on local business websites walks through the chamber, BBB and Nextdoor in more detail.

For the free listings that pass the scorecard, our list of 100 places to list your dental website is a good place to find more. If you want to grow links beyond directories, read our link building guide for dentists and our dental guest posting sites list.

Keep track of every directory you join

Once you start listing, keep a record. Note the directory name, the live listing URL, the score you gave it, the cost and the renewal date. Check each listing twice a year to make sure your details are still right.

Matching details matter because patients and search engines compare them. A citation tool can save time once you pass a dozen listings. Our guide to dental citation management software compares the main options.

Are dental directory links still good for SEO?

Links from real dental, health and local directories can still help, especially for local rankings. Google says local prominence depends partly on how many websites link to your business. Links from low-quality directories built to sell links do not help, and Google names them as link spam.

Is a nofollow directory listing worth having?

Yes, if real patients use the directory. A nofollow link does not pass ranking credit, but the listing can still send patients to your practice. It also confirms your name, address and phone number on another trusted site.

Should I remove my practice from spammy directories?

Ask the directory to remove a listing if it sits on an obvious spam site and you did not ask to be there. Keep a record of your requests. If you have bought links in the past, talk to your SEO agency about cleaning them up.

How long should a directory review take?

Our scorecard takes about ten minutes per directory. That small step saves money on paid listings and keeps your link profile clean.